Methodology assessment for the design and analysis of aero-engine short intakes

A key aspect for the design of an aero-engine intake is that it must operate at off-design conditions such as high incidence. For short intake design the interaction with the fan cannot be neglected. This work establishes how different modelling strategies can affect the intake design boundaries and the analysis of an aero-engine short-intake. Unsteady simulations showed high levels of total pressure and swirl fluctuations while steady computations showed some limitations whenever extreme operating conditions are modelled. The analysis of a short intake showed that the fan is able to extend the incidence limit to avoid separation by about 0.6°. Overall, this work proposes a robust methodology for short-intake analysi

Fan-intake aerodynamic interactions under crosswind conditions

The aerodynamics of an aero-engine intake under off-design conditions is characterized by a range of steady and unsteady mechanisms that can adversely affect the fan operability. A hierarchical computational fluid dynamics approach was used for an initial assessment of the primary aerodynamic interactions between the fan and the intake design. These approaches included steady computations with a lower order fan model as well as full unsteady computations. For a powered intake in crosswind, the direction of the wind determines the direction of rotation of the ground vortex relative to the fan. For the full unsteady analyses, the threshold crosswind speed reduced by 12kts and 22kts relative to the steady analysis for the counter-rotating and co-rotating configuration respectively. Overall, this work identified and assessed for the first time a fan-intake unsteady aerodynamic interactions that may affect the design of short intakes in association with fan systems

Aerodynamics of a short intake in crosswind

The next generation of turbofan aero-engines are likely to have an increase in fan diameter to reduce the specific thrust and increase the overall propulsive efficiency. More compact nacelles with possibly shorter intakes may be used to reduce weight and drag and achieve a net reduction of fuel consumption. For these compact nacelles a key consideration is the design of the short intake at the off-design conditions such as crosswind and high incidence operations. The close coupled interaction between a short intake and the fan at these off-design conditions is one of the key challenges. Previous work focused on the impact of short intake aerodynamics on the fan but there is a similar requirement to understand the impact of the fan on the viable short intake design space. This paper addresses the influence of the fan on the separation onset of the flow within a short intake under crosswind conditions. The effect of the fan on the separation characteristics of the intake boundary layer was considered both from a steady and an unsteady point of view. A hierarchy of fan computational models was used to separately assess the different aerodynamic contributions and to evaluate a net effect of the fan on the intake critical condition. Steady computational fluid dynamics analyses showed a notable positive effect of the fan on total pressure loss at post-separation conditions relative to a configuration without the fan. However, unsteady analyses revealed that fan unsteadiness has an adverse impact on the intake separation characteristics which reduces the intake critical conditions by about 15%. The main mechanisms behind the unsteady interaction were identified. Overall this work addresses, for the first time, the role of fan unsteadiness on the separation characteristics of the boundary layer within a short intake in crosswind

Effect of unsteady fan-intake interaction on short intake design

The next generation of ultra-high bypass ratio civil aero-engines promises notable engine cycle benefits. However, these benefits can be significantly eroded by a possible increase in nacelle weight and drag due to the typical larger fan diameters. More compact nacelles, with shorter intakes, may be required to enable a net reduction in aero-engine fuel burn. The aim of this paper is to assess the influence of the design style of short intakes on the unsteady interaction under crosswind conditions between fan and intake, with a focus on the separation onset and characteristics of the boundary layer within the intake. Three intake designs were assessed and a hierarchical computational fluid dynamics approach was used to determine and quantify primary aerodynamic interactions between the fan and the intake design. Similar to previous findings for a specific intake configuration, both intake flow unsteadiness and the unsteady upstream perturbations from the fan have a detrimental effect on the separation onset for the range of intake designs. The separation of the boundary layer within the intake was shock driven for the three different design styles. The simulations also quantified the unsteady intake flows with an emphasis on the spectral characteristics and engine-order signatures of the flow distortion. Overall, this work showed that is beneficial for the intake boundary layer to delay the diffusion closer to the fan and reduce the pre-shock Mach number to mitigate the adverse unsteady interaction between the fan and the shock

Characteristics of shock-induced boundary-layer separation on nacelles under windmilling diversion conditions

The boundary layer on the external cowl of an aeroengine nacelle under windmilling diversion conditions is subjected to a notable adverse pressure gradient due to the interaction with a near-normal shock wave. Within the context of computational fluid dynamics (CFD) methods, the correct representation of the characteristics of the boundary layer is a major challenge in capturing the onset of the separation. This is important for the aerodynamic design of the nacelle, as it may assist in the characterization of candidate designs. This work uses experimental data obtained from a quasi-2D rig configuration to provide an assessment of the CFD methods typically used within an industrial context. A range of operating conditions are investigated to assess the sensitivity of the boundary layer to changes in inlet Mach number and mass flow through a notional windmilling engine. Fully turbulent and transitional boundary-layer computations are used to determine the characteristics of the boundary layer and the interaction with the shock on the nacelle cowl. The correlation between the onset of shock-induced boundary-layer separation and the preshock Mach number is assessed, and it was found that the CFD is able to discern the onset of boundary-layer separation

A comparative assessment of multi-objective optimisation methodologies for aero-engine nacelles

There are significant environmental and economic drivers for the development of more fuel-efficient commercial aircraft engines. The propulsive efficiency benefits of ultra-high bypass ratio turbofans may be counteracted by the drag and weight penalty associated with larger nacelles. A more compact nacelle design may therefore be necessary to reduce these penalties. However, increasing compactness also increases the sensitivity of the nacelle to boundary layer separation under off-design windmilling conditions. This paper investigates methods for incorporating windmilling considerations alongside design point requirements within a multi-objective, multi-point optimisation. Windmilling under aircraft diversion and at the end-of-runway (EoR) condition are considered. The windmilling conditions are assessed through a combination of regression and classification type criteria. The transonic aerodynamics of the nacelle at the design point are notably different from the transonic characteristics at the diversion windmilling conditions. Meanwhile, the aerodynamics, and separation mechanisms, at the end-of-runway condition are dominated by subsonic diffusion. Overall, a combination of regression and classification mechanisms are found to be most suitable for the nacelle optimization as it delivers a design population which is favorably balanced between robustness against boundary layer separation as well as delivering nacelle drag benefits

Deep-learning for flow-field prediction of 3D non-axisymmetric aero-engine nacelles

Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) methods have been widely used for the design and optimisation of complex non-linear systems. Within this context, the overall process can typically have a large computational overhead. For preliminary design studies, it is important to establish design capabilities that meet the usually conflicting requirements of rapid evaluations and accuracy. Of particular interest is the aerodynamic design of components or subsystems within the transonic range. This can pose notable challenges due to the non-linearity of this flow regime. There is a need to develop low order models for future civil aero-engine nacelle applications. The aerodynamics of compact nacelles can be sensitive to changes in geometry and operating conditions. For example, within the cruise segment different flow-field characteristics may be encountered such as shock-wave boundary layer interaction or shock induced separation. As such, an important step in the successful design of these new architectures is to develop methods for fast and accurate flow-field prediction. This work studies two different metamodelling approaches for flow-field prediction of 3D non-axisymmetric nacelles. Firstly, a reduced order model based on an artificial neural network (ANN) is considered. Secondly, a low order model that combines singular value decomposition and an artificial neural network (SVD+ANN) is investigated. Across a wide geometric design space, the ANN and SVD+ANN methods have an overall uncertainty in the isentropic Mach number prediction of about 0.02. However, the ANN approach has better capabilities to predict pre-shock Mach numbers and shock-wave locations.European Union funding: 10100759

Aerodynamics of a compact nacelle at take-off conditions

Next generation ultra-high bypass ratio turbofans may have larger fan diameters than the previous generation of aircraft engines. This will potentially increase the nacelle diameter and may incur penalties to the weight and drag of the powerplant. To offset these penalties, a more compact nacelle may be used. Compact nacelles may be more sensitive to boundary layer separation at the end-of-runway conditions, particularly at an off-design windmilling operating point. Additionally, the flow separation on the external cowl surface is likely to be influenced by the integration between the powerplant, pylon and airframe. The publicly available NASA high lift common research model (HL-CRM) with take-off flap and slat settings was modified to accommodate an ultra-high bypass ratio powerplant. The powerplant has an intake, separate jet exhaust, external cowl and pylon. Boundary layer separation on the external cowl of the compact powerplant is assessed at end-of-runway rated take-off and take-off windmilling scenarios. Additionally, the lift curve and Cp distributions of the high lift common research model (HL-CRM) are compared for rated take-off and take-off windmilling engine mass flows. Overall, the nacelle boundary layer separates from the nacelle highlight at windmilling conditions when the engine mass flow is relatively low. The mechanism of separation at windmilling conditions is diffusion driven and is initiated on the nacelle aft-body. The pylon has a small impact on the overall mechanism of separation. However, the wing and high-lift devices of the HL-CRM introduce local separation on the external cowl. The HL-CRM wing with the installed powerplant stalls at a similar angle (αa/c = 16°) to the HL-CRM with the through flow nacelle available in the open literature. Compared with the nominal take-off condition, the maximum lift coefficient of the HL-CRM airframe was reduced by about 2% under windmilling engine mass flows

Design of a quasi-2D rig configuration to assess nacelle aerodynamics under windmilling conditions

Aero-engine nacelles are typically designed to fulfil both design and off-design aircraft manoeuvres. Under-off design conditions one of the objective is to avoid large flow separation either on the external cowl or within the intake that can influence aircraft and engine operability. One particular scenario is represented by a low engine mass flow regime associated with one inoperative engine, also known as a windmilling condition. Under windmilling, the boundary layer on the external cowl of the nacelle can separate either due to the interaction with shockwaves or due to notable adverse pressure gradient towards the trailing edge. Both mechanisms are computationally difficult to model and there is a need for more validation of computational fluid dynamics (CFD) methods. The aim of this work is to develop a rig configuration which will provide CFD validation data for the aerodynamics of a nacelle under representative windmilling conditions. Two flight regimes are considered, namely windmilling diversion and end-of-runway. CFD simulations of a 3D nacelle are used to determine primary aerodynamic mechanisms associated with boundary layer separation. Two rig configurations are developed and both 2D and 3D CFD analyses are used to achieve the design objectives. Overall, this work presents the design philosophy and methods that were pursued to develop a quasi-2D rig configuration representative of the aerodynamics of 3D-annular aero-engine nacelles under windmilling conditions.European Union funding: 10100759

Experimental Investigation of Transonic External Fan Cowl Separation

When a civil aircraft engine is shut down during the cruise phase of flight and thus begins to windmill, a supersonic region forms on the external surface of the fan cowl. The terminating normal shock can separate the turbulent boundary layer developing on this external surface. A series of experiments are performed in a quasi- two-dimensional wind tunnel rig to investigate the influence of various parameters on this flow problem. As the engine mass-flow rate is reduced, an increase in normal shock strength results in the onset of flow separation which thickens the boundary layer developing on the external fan cowl surface by a factor of three. A reduction in incoming Mach number from the nominal value of 0.65 to 0.60 weakens the shock wave and thus delays flow separation. If the incoming boundary layer is laminar rather than turbulent, the normal shock Mach number is observed to increased by 10%. Despite the stronger shock, no significant flow separation can be detected even for the lowest engine mass-flow rates studied and the external nacelle surface boundary layer is measured to be thinner than for the turbulent case.This project has received funding from the Clean Sky 2 Joint Undertaking (JU) under grant agreement No 101007598. The JU receives support from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme and the Clean Sky 2 JU members other than the Union